The Crowded Street – Winifred Holtby


 ‘the thing that matters is to take your life into your own hands and live it, accepting responsibility for failure or success.  The really fatal thing to do is to let other people make your choices for you, and then to blame them if your schemes should fail and they despise you for the failure.’

Muriel, the books main character spends most of the book working towards this understanding of her life, a life where  ‘men do as they like’ but women ‘wait to see what they will do’.


I had read a couple of other of Winifred Holtby’s novels many years ago, “South Riding” and “Anderby Wold”, but this one had evaded me. So it’s thanks to the 1924 Club for this late discovery. Click on the image below to find out more about the club.


Of the three books I have read for this reading club, this is the one I enjoyed the most.

Muriel grows up in a small Yorkshire village with all the benefits and restrictions this entails. Most of the restrictions are laid down by her domineering, social climber of a mother for whom “respectability” is everything. We follow Muriel up to and through the First World War as she aspires to find a husband or some role in life away from marriage. The chapter headings all refer to major influences and responsibilities in her life (her sister, her mother, etc), except the last and shortest chapter entitled “Muriel”. The gradual realisation by Muriel about her life is handled superbly, as she moves through life dedicating herself to others until she finally faces up to herself and her predicament. A predicament faced by most women at that time, whose only purpose was to make a “good” marriage.

I lived in York and Leeds for nearly 30 years so the area portrayed was very real to me, even though the mixing of real and imaginary places could be a bit confusing at times, to anyone local. The scenes around the bombardment of Scarborough during the First World War are particularly vivid as the War is brought brutally right into people’s homes.


3 thoughts on “The Crowded Street – Winifred Holtby

  1. I meant to read this one this week, but somehow didn’t manage to get beyond p.3. But this positive review encourages me to go back to it when I’m more in the right mood! Thanks so much for your contributions this week. I think I’ll ask, at the end, which year people would choose next time.


  2. Excellent! Like Simon I would’ve liked to get round to this one, but time ran out on me. Glad you enjoyed it – it seems to have been received very positively by those who read it!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s